ARTICLE

Zapier or Make: Which workflow tool is better? (Updated)

Most Read
Tools
Technology
Zapier or Make: Which workflow tool is better? (Updated)Zapier or Make: Which workflow tool is better? (Updated)

Interface automation, using APIs, is becoming more and more the focus of automation experts. Today we take a closer look at the two dominant tools in the cloud BPA scene and compare the two: which is better, Zapier or Make?

Zapier: strong design and easy entry

Zapier shines with an easy-to-use user interface and intuitive operation. For each workflow - also called Zap - the tool provides dummy data with which each integrated interface can be integrated and immediately tested. This feature makes it much easier for the user to find any errors.

For the developers among us, Zapier offers the possibility to execute own Python or Javascript code within the Zaps. This allows savvy professionals to further increase the individuality and functionality of the automated workflow. 

Both a curse and a blessing are the number of apps - about 2,000+ in number. The sheer number of apps can be a bit overwhelming, especially at first, but if you look a little closer, you'll notice that not all file-modifying POST or file-fetching GET routes are always already available in Zapier. Furthermore, not all of the 2,000+ apps are immediately accessible in Zapier, but are declared as premium apps, which can limit the selection depending on the packages you choose.

If the project becomes more complex and the process larger, things can get tight with Zapier: A maximum of three paths can be mapped in a workflow. This leads to the fact that If statements can only be nested twice.

One of the biggest shortcomings concerns only us Europeans, which refers to the ruling of the ECJ on the subject of the GDPR. Zapier is a US company and, according to the latest ruling, does not comply with the European data protection directives.

Zapier: Summary

Thee Pros and Cons of Zapier

UPDATE: Zapier renewed its Terms of Service on Aug. 31, 2020, and aims to provide more transparency around the use of private data as well as security.

Here's what has changed, according to the data:

In the Terms of Service, there is also the information that Zapier operates within the so-called EU-U.S. Privacy Shield Framework, which should not be confused with the GDPR Regulation. This is merely a mechanism that allows participating companies to comply with EU requirements for the transfer of personal data to third countries. 

Make: great technical possibilities

Compared to Zapier, Make represents the tool for more complex landscapes and is ideally suited for clearly mapping even larger processes. In addition, make offers the possibility to adapt and rearrange the workflow as desired. In practice, we rarely see processes that have been defined once and are never adapted again. This possibility makes Make very attractive as a modular solution.

From a European perspective, there is another decisive advantage: The company behind the software tool comes from the Czech Republic. Accordingly, Make operates in compliance with the GDPR.

Data processing as well as data storage at Make are also advanced. There is the possibility to save results and data for further processes. Make also makes it very easy to track what data is sent where via API call.

A sorely missed feature is that of code execution. With Make, it is unfortunately not possible to quickly write a Python script and have it executed within the workflow.

Make can do a lot and is great for more complex processes, but the documentation is not very detailed.

Make: Summary

The Pros and Cons of Make (Integromat)

Zapier vs Make: Which tool is better?

Zapier is suitable for a quick and easy introduction to the subject and for implementing initial processes. Makeshould be used when the processes become more complex. In the enterprise context, we would always reach for Make if the DSGVO plays a major role and is mandatory. For those who want to delve further into process automation in the cloud, take a look at our article on Integrated Platform as a Service (iPaaS).

Want more?
Dig in!

Process Automation Explained: Everything You Need To Know
Technology

Process Automation Explained: Everything You Need To Know

Digitization
Organisation
Business Processes - Why They Are Essential for Your Start-Up
Organisation

Business Processes - Why They Are Essential for Your Start-Up

Digitization
Use Cases
Future of Work: New Trends That Will Change Work Forever
Digitization

Future of Work: New Trends That Will Change Work Forever

Technology
Digitization
Organisation
Education
The Future is Now: What does Process Automation Mean for Your Future?
Digitization

The Future is Now: What does Process Automation Mean for Your Future?

Education
Organisation
Technology
Careers in Process Automation
Education

Careers in Process Automation

Digitization
Organisation
Technology
Top 9 Revolutionary Tech Trends You Need To Know in 2022
Digitization

Top 9 Revolutionary Tech Trends You Need To Know in 2022

Technology
Digitization

Check out our
Success Stories

Case Study

Placeholder Text. Do not edit. Slides will get generated based on content from CMS.

Placeholder Text. Do not edit. Slides will get generated based on content from CMS.Placeholder Text. Do not edit. Case Studie Slides will get edited via CMS.Download E-book

Placeholder Text. Do not edit. Case Studie Slides will get edited via CMS.

Placeholder Text. Do not edit. Case Studie Slides will get edited via CMS.
Case Study

T-Systems

Automation Pioneer Program: jointly organized by T-Systems International, RWTH Business School and Bots & People. The aim was to train technology consultants and sales staff in the field of process automation in order to build up in-house expertise.

Download E-book

Process mining and process automation are key technologies of digitalization in organizations seeking transparency and optimization of business processes. The new Automation Pioneer program is a great opportunity for participants to learn about these hot topics in today's industrial market.

Dr. Seran Uysal
RWTH Aachen University, Group Leader at Process and Data Science Chair
Case Study

eCommerce Automation

This use case covers the automation of procurement at a large German eCommerce company for electronic devices. This project was planned, executed and supported by Bots & People and is considered a success story of process automation in the company.

Download E-book

Hybrid process automation using Robotic Process Automation (RPA) and API automation is a common method. For the employees of the electronics manufacturer, automation has greatly simplified their everyday work. The free time resources can now be put into new, creative projects. And best of all, this use case can be copied and used universally.

Nico Bitzer
Bots & People, CEO & Co-Founder

DOnt be shy.
Hit us up!

NO MORE BORING
NO MORE BORING
NO MORE BORING